Home › Guides › PCN appeal rejected

PCN appeal rejected? What to do next (and why most people give up too early)

Sourced guide · Updated 11 November 2026 · England and Wales

Short answer: A rejected informal challenge is not the end. Wait for the Notice to Owner, make formal representations within 28 days on the statutory grounds, and if those are rejected appeal to the free independent tribunal within 28 days. In 2025-26 the Traffic Penalty Tribunal allowed 41.6% of appeals and 67.5% of those wins were not contested by the council.

What a rejection letter actually means

Councils answer most first challenges with a template rejection. It is written by the same department that issued the ticket. The decisions that matter come later: formal representations, which statutory guidance says the council must give "a fresh and impartial consideration", and then the independent adjudicator, who decides on the evidence and is not bound by anything the council said.

The three stages after a rejection

  1. Notice to Owner. Arrives after the 28-day PCN period (for postal camera PCNs the notice itself is the formal stage). You have 28 days to make formal representations. Most councils re-offer the 50% discount for 14 days when they reject an informal challenge, so check the wording of your letter.
  2. Formal representations. Made on the statutory grounds in regulation 5 of the Civil Enforcement of Road Traffic Contraventions (Representations and Appeals) (England) Regulations 2022. The council must reply within 56 days or your representations are "deemed to have been accepted".
  3. Tribunal appeal. Within 28 days of the Notice of Rejection, to the Traffic Penalty Tribunal (England outside London, and Wales) or London Tribunals. Free, online, no solicitor needed. The council has to send its evidence to the tribunal within seven days.

The nine grounds you can use

Regulation 5(4) lists them: the contravention did not occur; you were not the owner at the time; the vehicle was taken without consent; you are a hire firm with a signed liability statement; the penalty exceeded the amount applicable; there has been a procedural impropriety by the council; the traffic order is invalid; a postal PCN wrongly claims the officer was prevented from serving it; the penalty was already paid. Separately, you can ask the council to cancel for "compelling reasons" whether or not a ground applies.

The two that win most often are the first and the sixth. "The contravention did not occur" covers loading, valid tickets and permits, the 10-minute grace period in paid bays, camera footage that does not show what the PCN says, and signs or markings that do not substantially comply with the Traffic Signs Regulations. "Procedural impropriety" covers the council's own failures: a postal PCN later than 28 days, a Notice to Owner later than six months, a notice missing required wording, or no reply within 56 days. The High Court has said such a failure "is fatal to the recovery of a penalty charge" and that you do not need to show you were disadvantaged.

What the adjudicator will not accept

Mitigating circumstances. London Tribunals says plainly that they "are not allowable as grounds of appeal", and the Court of Appeal confirmed it in Walmsley v TfL (2005). A breakdown, an emergency or an honest mistake belongs in the compelling-reasons section of your representations to the council, and at the tribunal only as a request that the adjudicator recommend cancellation, which the council must then reconsider within 35 days.

The official numbers

TribunalAppeals allowedWins not contested by the council
Traffic Penalty Tribunal, England outside London and Wales, 2025-2641.6%67.5%
London Tribunals, parking, 2024-2549.3%68.5%
London Tribunals, bus lanes, 2024-2554.2%91.2%

Two thirds of successful appeals are won because the council did not turn up to defend the case. A rejection letter tells you almost nothing about whether it will.

How to write the letter

One to two pages. A header with the PCN number, registration and the regulation you are using. A one-paragraph summary. Numbered grounds, each with the facts, an exhibit reference and the legal consequence in a sentence. Compelling reasons last and labelled. The outcome you want. An evidence list. The adjudicator in Hatfield v TfL criticised a 13-page unstructured submission; structure is the point.

PCN Rejected? The Reply Pack · £9

Council PCNs. The nine legal grounds, what the tribunal looks for, and eight copy-and-fill letters for every stage after the first no. Editable Word letters included.

Coming to Payhip this week · £9 What’s inside →

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to appeal after a rejection?

28 days from the Notice to Owner to make formal representations, and 28 days from the Notice of Rejection to appeal to the tribunal. The adjudicator can accept a late appeal if you give reasons.

Will I lose the discount if I appeal again?

Most councils re-offer the 14-day discount when rejecting an informal challenge. After formal representations and a tribunal appeal the full amount is payable if you lose, so decide on the strength of your grounds. Appealing to the tribunal itself is free.

Does the tribunal cost anything?

No. London Tribunals and the Traffic Penalty Tribunal are free. Costs are only awarded against an appellant who acts frivolously, vexatiously or wholly unreasonably.

Can I appeal on mitigating circumstances?

Not at the tribunal. Send them to the council as compelling reasons under regulation 5(2)(b)(ii), or ask the adjudicator to recommend cancellation under regulation 7(8).

Sources

Let the app write it

Photograph the notice and Appeal My PCN drafts the letter around your ticket. First appeal free, no account.